Pool Resurfacing vs Replastering: What’s the Difference?

Pool resurfacing vs replastering is a question we hear often at All County Pools & Spa—are they the same, and which one does your pool really need? While the terms are sometimes used interchangeably, they actually refer to different processes with unique purposes and results. In this guide, we’ll explain the key differences between resurfacing and replastering, what each involves, and how to choose the right solution for restoring and enhancing your pool.

Key Takeaways

• Replastering is a form of resurfacing but specifically involves replacing the plaster layer.
• Resurfacing is a broader term that includes a variety of finishes like plaster, pebble, quartz, or tile.
• Choosing between resurfacing and replastering depends on the current condition of your pool and the finish you desire.
• Replastering is often more cost-effective, while resurfacing can offer enhanced aesthetics and longevity.
• All County Pools & Spa can help guide you through the decision-making process and execute your pool restoration with precision and care.

What is Pool Replastering?

Let’s start with replastering. Pool replastering is the process of removing the old, deteriorating plaster from your pool and applying a new layer. Plaster is the most common pool finish, made from a mixture of white cement, limestone or marble sand, and water.

When your plaster starts to show signs of aging — like discoloration, rough patches, or cracking — it’s time to consider replastering. This process restores the smooth texture and aesthetic appeal of your pool surface, making it look and feel like new again.

Replastering is typically required every 7 to 10 years, depending on how well the pool has been maintained.

Why Choose Replastering?

Here are several compelling reasons to consider it:

• Cost-effective: It’s often less expensive than other resurfacing options.
• Quick turnaround: Generally takes less time to complete.
• Tried and true: Traditional plaster has a long track record of success.

But there’s a caveat: standard plaster is less durable than other resurfacing materials and more prone to staining and etching over time.

What is Pool Resurfacing?

Pool resurfacing refers to the complete overhaul of the pool’s interior finish. It includes replastering, but also encompasses more premium materials such as:

• Pebble finishes
• Quartz finishes
• Glass bead surfaces
• Tile installations

Resurfacing is often done when the pool has more extensive surface damage or when you want to upgrade the visual appeal and durability of your pool. It not only refreshes the look of your pool but can also significantly extend its lifespan.

Types of Resurfacing Finishes

 Here are some common types of resurfacing finishes to consider:

1. Pebble Finish

Pebble finishes combine small river pebbles with cement. These surfaces are incredibly durable and resistant to chemicals and stains.

• Textured and natural look
• Lasts up to 15-20 years
• Great for custom designs and colors

2. Quartz Finish

Quartz finishes mix quartz crystals with plaster, offering a more vibrant and durable surface than standard plaster.

• Smooth, colorful appearance
• Higher resistance to etching
• Typically lasts 12-15 years

3. Glass Bead Finish

Glass beads offer a high-end, luminous finish that gives the water a sparkling effect.

• Extremely aesthetic appeal
• Smooth surface
• Reflective properties enhance pool lighting

4. Tile Finish

Tile is the premium choice for pool finishes. Although the most expensive, it offers unparalleled beauty and longevity.

• Custom patterns and colors
• Lasts decades with proper care
• Resistant to most types of wear and tear

Pool Resurfacing vs Replastering: What’s the Real Difference?

At first glance, replastering may seem like a type of resurfacing — and that’s because it is. However, not all resurfacing is replastering.

Let’s put it this way: replastering is the basic level of resurfacing. When you replaster your pool, you’re opting to replace the surface with a similar material. When you resurface your pool, you may choose to upgrade to a more durable or visually appealing finish.

Comparison Chart

When Should You Choose to Replaster vs Resurface?

We recommend replastering when:

• Your pool surface is worn but structurally sound.
• You want a cost-effective restoration.
• You’re satisfied with the traditional plaster look and feel.

Resurfacing is a better option when:

• You’re experiencing severe surface degradation.
• You want a more durable or modern finish.
• You’re looking to completely revamp your pool’s aesthetic.

At All County Pools & Spa, we help homeowners evaluate the condition of their pool and choose the best option. Sometimes a simple replaster is all you need. Other times, going with a high-end resurfacing material is the better long-term investment.

Our Process at All County Pools & Spa

Whether you choose replastering or resurfacing, we follow a meticulous and customer-focused process to ensure your pool restoration exceeds expectations:

1. Inspection & Consultation — We assess your pool’s condition and review your goals.
2. Surface Preparation — We drain the pool and prep the surface by chipping out old materials.
3. Application — New plaster or chosen finish is expertly applied.
4. Curing & Fill-Up — After the surface sets, we refill the pool and monitor the water chemistry.
5. Walkthrough — We walk you through the finished work and provide care instructions.

We prioritize clarity, communication, and craftsmanship every step of the way.

Cost Considerations

Pricing will vary depending on:

• The size of your pool
• The current condition of your surface
• The finish you choose

Replaster or Resurface? Let’s Make Your Dream Pool a Reality

Understanding the difference between pool resurfacing and replastering is key to making the right investment for your backyard oasis. At All County Pools & Spa, we’re here to guide you through every step, whether your goal is to refresh your pool with a simple plaster job or transform it with a luxurious new finish.

Let’s bring your vision to life.

Ready to give your pool a new lease on life? Call us at 818-720-3316 to schedule a free consultation. Whether you’re leaning toward replastering or considering a full resurfacing, our experienced team is here to help.

Visit our website or speak directly with our specialists. At All County Pools & Spa, your dream pool is just one call away.